Choosing between an internal team and an agency includes comparing price, experience, and flexibility between these two. An internal team knows your brand well and offers direct control over campaigns. But it’s more costly to maintain due to salaries and other factors.
Agencies on one hand provide special skills and tools but may not know your business as well as you do. Smaller firms in U.S. prefer agencies due to their affordability while larger brands often hire an internal team to meet their unique needs.
What is an In-House Team?
It means hiring experts who will work only for your company and focus on improving your website’s performance in search results. They join your brand and work closely with your marketing, product, and development teams.
Since their SEO services are only for your brand, they can easily adjust their strategies for a new product and the U.S. market.
What is an SEO Agency?
It is an independent agency that helps various firms improve their search engine rankings. It includes experts in link building, SEM, and backlinking services.
They handle all your needs, so you don’t have to train and hire people. You pay them for free either regularly or per task. It makes things like budgeting and changing services easy.
In-house vs. SEO Agency Pros and Cons
Deciding between two is key for businesses wanting to improve their online reach. Both options have strengths and weaknesses that can notably affect the outcomes. Learning such aspects is vital to choosing what works best for your business growth.
Pros of In-House SEO
- Complete Control
Having your team gives you complete control over keyword research and planning. It ensures that everything aligns with your company’s goals and regulations in the U.S. market. Being in charge also allows you to make much quicker changes without delays.
- Brand Knowledge
An internal team clearly understands your brand and customers. It results in more solid content and campaigns that help you connect better with your target audiences. It can significantly boost the overall reach and effectiveness of your marketing campaign.
- Smooth Collaboration
Since your internal team works closely with experts in other departments, you can swiftly make changes regarding your website, such as fixing technical issues or updating its content. It helps you react faster to algorithm updates and market changes.
Cons of In-House SEO
- Higher Maintenance Cost
Hiring an internal team with benefits costs around $60,000 to $90,000 annually. You must also count the benefits that cost about 30% of the total benefits. Add additional costs like hiring fees and an estimated $3,000 yearly for training per person.
- Recruitment Challenges
SEO experts are in demand in the market. So you must give them generous pay and chances for career growth and development. Smaller companies in the U.S. can find it hard to fulfill such demands. This is why many small firms here still prefer an SEO agency.
- Skill Gaps
SEO covers a lot of different things, such as technical audits, content planning, link building, and data monitoring. Finding a single person with expertise in all these areas is hard. Since one person can’t do it all, you may not perform well unless you hire a team.
Pros of an SEO Agency
- Affordable Solutions
Hiring an agency costs around $2,500 to $7,500 every month. It provides access to various tools and experts without a new hire investment. Agencies share their tools and expenses across multiple clients. It helps you save money for your business.
- Broader Skill Set
Such agencies have expertise in different areas, like content planning, link building, and data monitoring. Plus, they have comprehensive knowledge from working with other types of businesses. It’s best for firms eager to learn best practices in diverse verticals.
- Quick Start and Flexibility
Good agencies always spend on getting the latest tools and techniques on the market. So, their plans stay updated with the newest Google policies, and you don’t have to pay extra. It ensures your website maintains its position and improves its rankings.
Cons of an SEO Agency
- Lesser Control
Working with an agency introduces several communication layers. Your project priorities may sometimes compete with others as an agency deals with multiple clients simultaneously. So regular meetings and clear agreements are key to staying on track.
- Quality Variation
Not all agencies do a good job. Many firms promise a lot but deliver less. It costs companies their valuable time and money. There have been many incidents in the past where brands paid a lot but got much less in return.
- Conflicting Goals
Some agencies try to sell you add-on services and make you sign extended contracts to boost their revenue, even if it’s not necessary. You must check them out before purchasing and ensure they are transparent. It will help avoid unnecessary expenses.
In-House vs. SEO Agency Cost
Cost is vital when choosing between an internal team and an agency. But accurate comparison goes beyond agency fees and you must include all expenses of an internal team before making a choice.
| Cost Factors | In-House Team | SEO Agency |
| Salary for SEO Experts | $60,000-$90,000 | Not Included |
| Benefits and Overhead | $18,000-$27,000 | Not Included |
| Training and Development | $3000+ | $167-$417 |
| SEO Tools and Subscriptions | $6,000-$24,000 | $500-$2,000 |
| Recruitment Cost | $5,000-$15,000 | Not Included |
| Total Cost | $92,000-$159,000 annually | $30,000-$90,000 annually ($2.5k-$7.5k monthly) |
Small businesses hires an SEO agency to get better results for their investments in first year. But larger brands planning to spend money on SEO for a longer period should consider having their own internal team.
How to choose between In-House and SEO Agency
Companies must make the right choice between these two for better results. This decision depends on factors including cost, control, scale, and growth.
- Investment Capacity
If your annual budget for SEO is under $100,000, it would be better to hire an external agency for your business. But if your budget is more than $200,000, it would be better for you to build an internal team for your brand. It will help you do better in the long run.
- Control and Brand Immersion
Companies working in sectors like finance and healthcare prefer to have their internal team. It helps them ensure that everything that’s being done follows the law. Plus, consumer brands needing rapid content changes may benefit internally..
- Better Results
Agencies can start their work immediately with their experts. Hiring an internal team on the other hand takes about three to six months. So, if you have time-sensitive campaigns like holiday sales, using an agency will get things started much faster.
Conclusion
There is no single solution for your SEO needs. Companies with tight budgets and deadlines benefit from agencies for quicker access to experts. But brands with lasting SEO goals and sweeping rules may benefit from an internal team, and some firms even combine both.
Considering factors like your budget, scale, and goals will help you make the best choice. You can also check out our professional SEO services to learn more and get custom solutions for your business.
FAQs
Q1. What is the difference between in-house and SEO agency?
Your internal team manages an in-house SEO. It offers more control and brand alignment. An SEO agency provides diverse skills and experience but offers less control.
Q2. Are SEO agencies worth it?
Such agencies are worth investing in if you need specialized skills and growth. But make sure to check their past works and prices to see whether they suit your needs.
Q3. What is the advantage of using an in-house agency?
Using an internal team provides you with an unmatched brand affinity. They are involved with your products and customers, so their plans match your brand voice and goals.
Q4. How to structure an in-house creative team?
Separate the team based on what they do. It includes a creative director, art director, copywriter, designer, and producer. Assign contacts for marketing and UX for synergy,
Also Read:
